April 2010 Progress Report

New releases

  • On April 24, we released Tor This version addresses the recent connection and memory overload problems we’ve been seeing on relays, especially relays with their DirPort open. If your relay has been crashing, or you turned it off because it used too many resources, give this release a try.

    o Major bugfixes:
    - Teach relays to defend themselves from connection overload. Relays
    now close idle circuits early if it looks like they were intended
    for directory fetches. Relays are also more aggressive about closing
    TLS connections that have no circuits on them. Such circuits are
    unlikely to be re-used, and tens of thousands of them were piling
    up at the fast relays, causing the relays to run out of sockets
    and memory. Bugfix on (where clients started tunneling
    their directory fetches over TLS).

    o Minor features:
    - Finally get rid of the deprecated and now harmful notion of "clique
    mode", where directory authorities maintain TLS connections to
    every other relay.
    - Directory authorities now do an immediate reachability check as soon
    as they hear about a new relay. This change should slightly reduce
    the time between setting up a relay and getting listed as running
    in the consensus. It should also improve the time between setting
    up a bridge and seeing use by bridge users.
    - Directory authorities no longer launch a TLS connection to every
    relay as they startup. Now that we have 2k+ descriptors cached,
    the resulting network hiccup is becoming a burden. Besides,
    authorities already avoid voting about Running for the first half
    hour of their uptime.

  • On April 20, 2010 we released Tor This release fixes a critical bug in how directory authorities handle and vote on descriptors. It was causing relays to drop out of the consensus.

    Changes in version - 2010-04-20
    o Major bugfixes:
    - Many relays have been falling out of the consensus lately because
    not enough authorities know about their descriptor for them to get
    a majority of votes. When we deprecated the v2 directory protocol,
    we got rid of the only way that v3 authorities can hear from each
    other about other descriptors. Now authorities examine every v3
    vote for new descriptors, and fetch them from that authority. Bugfix
    - Fix two typos in tor_vasprintf() that broke the compile on Windows,
    and a warning in or.h related to bandwidth_weight_rule_t that
    prevented clean compile on OS X. Fixes bug 1363; bugfix on
    - Fix a segfault on relays when DirReqStatistics is enabled
    and 24 hours pass. Bug found by keb. Fixes bug 1365; bugfix on

    o Minor bugfixes:
    - Demote a confusing TLS warning that relay operators might get when
    someone tries to talk to their OrPort. It is neither the operator's
    fault nor can they do anything about it. Fixes bug 1364; bugfix

  • On April 15, we released Tor It fixes yet another instance of broken OpenSSL libraries that was causing some relays to drop out of the consensus.

    o Major bugfixes:
    - Directory mirrors were fetching relay descriptors only from v2
    directory authorities, rather than v3 authorities like they should.
    Only 2 v2 authorities remain (compared to 7 v3 authorities), leading
    to a serious bottleneck. Bugfix on Fixes bug 1324.
    - Fix a parsing error that made every possible value of
    CircPriorityHalflifeMsec get treated as "1 msec". Bugfix
    on Rename CircPriorityHalflifeMsec to
    CircuitPriorityHalflifeMsec, so authorities can tell newer relays
    about the option without breaking older ones.
    - Fix SSL renegotiation behavior on OpenSSL versions like on Centos
    that claim to be earlier than 0.9.8m, but which have in reality
    backported huge swaths of 0.9.8m or 0.9.8n renegotiation
    behavior. Possible fix for some cases of bug 1346.

    o Minor features:
    - Experiment with a more aggressive approach to preventing clients
    from making one-hop exit streams. Exit relays who want to try it
    out can set "RefuseUnknownExits 1" in their torrc, and then look
    for "Attempt by %s to open a stream" log messages. Let us know
    how it goes!
    - Add support for statically linking zlib by specifying
    --enable-static-zlib, to go with our support for statically linking
    openssl and libevent. Resolves bug 1358.

    o Minor bugfixes:
    - Fix a segfault that happens whenever a Tor client that is using
    libevent2's bufferevents gets a hup signal. Bugfix on;
    fixes bug 1341.
    - When we cleaned up the contrib/tor-exit-notice.html file, we left
    out the first line. Fixes bug 1295.
    - When building the manpage from a tarball, we required asciidoc, but
    the asciidoc -> roff/html conversion was already done for the
    tarball. Make 'make' complain only when we need asciidoc (either
    because we're compiling directly from git, or because we altered
    the asciidoc manpage in the tarball). Bugfix on
    - When none of the directory authorities vote on any params, Tor
    segfaulted when trying to make the consensus from the votes. We
    didn't trigger the bug in practice, because authorities do include
    params in their votes. Bugfix on; fixes bug 1322.

    o Testsuite fixes:
    - In the util/threads test, no longer free the test_mutex before all
    worker threads have finished. Bugfix on
    - The master thread could starve the worker threads quite badly on
    certain systems, causing them to run only partially in the allowed
    window. This resulted in test failures. Now the master thread sleeps
    occasionally for a few microseconds while the two worker-threads
    compete for the mutex. Bugfix on

  • Tor Browser Bundle for GNU/Linux was updated throughout the month, from versions 1.0.1 to 1.0.4. The details are:
    1.0.4: Released 2010-04-24
    Update Tor to

    1.0.3: Released 2010-04-20
    Update Tor to

    1.0.2: Released 2010-04-18
    Update Tor to
    Update to Vidalia 0.2.8

    1.0.1: Released 2010-04-08
    Stop TBB from crashing when it tries to download files
    Update Torbutton to 1.2.5

  • On April 4, we released Tor Browser Bundle for Windows version 1.3.4. The changes were an update to Firefox 3.5.9 to address some security issues, and update the Torbutton Firefox extension to 1.2.5.
  • On April 8, we released the latest Torbutton Firefox Extension version, 1.2.5. This release includes a number of bugfixes and some new features. The details are:

    * bugfix: bug 1169: Fix blank popup conflict with CoolPreviews
    * bugfix: bug 1246: Fix IST and other HH:30 timezone issues.
    * bugfix: bug 1219: Fix the toggle warning loop issue on settings change.
    * bugfix: bug 1321: Fix a session restore bug when closing the last window
    * bugfix: bug 1302: Update useragent to FF3.6.3 on WinNT6.
    * bugfix: bug 1157: Add logic to handle torbutton crashed state conflicts
    * bugfix: bug 1235: Improve the 'changed-state' refresh warning message
    * bugfix: bug 1337: Bind alert windows to correct browser window
    * bugfix: bug 1055: Make the error console the default log output location
    * bugfix: bug 1032: Fix an exception in the localhost proxy filter
    * misc: Always tell a website our window size is rounded even if it's not
    * misc: Add some suggestions to warning about loading external content
    * new: Add option to always update Torbutton via Tor. On by default
    * new: Redirect Google queries elsewhere on captcha (default ixquick)
    * new: Strip identifying info off of Google searchbox queries

  • On April 11, we released Vidalia 0.2.8. It contains updated translations, updates to the universal plug and play libraries, and better compatibility with newer versions of the Nokia Qt toolkit.

    o Stop using our custom dock icon implementation on OS X and just use
    QSystemTrayIcon everywhere. Fixes the build on Snow Leopard.
    (Ticket #562)
    o Update the bundled CA certificates to re-enable downloading bridges
    from bridges.torproject.org via SSL.
    o Include a pre-configured qt.conf file in the Mac OS X bundles that
    disable Qt plugin loading from the default directories. Otherwise,
    users who have Qt installed in a system-wide location would end up
    loading the libraries twice and crashing.
    o Include libgcc_s_dw2-1.dll in the Windows installers, since Qt 4.6 now
    depends on that DLL. Including the .dll is currently hardcoded, so the
    Windows installer must be built using Qt 4.6. (Ticket #555)
    o Update the included version of miniupnpc to 1.4.20100407.
    o Add Burmese and Thai UI translations.

Design, develop, and implement enhancements that make Tor a better tool for users in censored countries.

Karsten did major backend processing work on the http://metrics.torproject.org data and website. These improvements allow for an automated process to update the various graphs and analyze the data sets. The whole system is better documented to assist someone in replicating the environment from scratch.

Outreach and Advocacy

Preconfigured privacy (circumvention) bundles for USB or LiveCD.

Released new versions of Tor Browser Bundle for GNU/Linux and Windows. See above for details.

Scalability, load balancing, directory overhead, efficiency.

From the release notes:
Directory authorities now do an immediate reachability check as soon as they hear about a new relay. This change should slightly reduce the time between setting up a relay and getting listed as running in the consensus. It should also improve the time between setting up a bridge and seeing use by bridge users.

In March, we changed a setting on a majority of the Directory Authorities called CircPriorityHalflifeMsec. Based upon research at the University of Waterloo, changing this setting could improve the overall performance of the network by fine tuning the earned weighted mean average bit bucket for better performance. Due to a bug in the CircPriorityHalflifeMsec parsing, the average latency in the network increased dramatically. At the same time, China unblocked the list of public and bridge relays, flooding hundreds of thousands of clients back into the network. It seems the network responded poorly to both events.

More reliable (e.g. split) download mechanism.

The GNU/Linux tor browser bundle with localizations was added to the get-tor email auto-responder.

Translation work, ultimately a browser-based approach.

  • Updated text strings for the get-tor email auto-responder to make it easier for translators to complete the work.
  • Added new translations of Vietnamese, Greek and Serbian to all projects.
  • Many updated translated strings in German, Polish, Greek, Dutch, Finnish, Russian, Japanese, Chinese, French, Burmese, Spanish, Farsi, Arabic, Swedish, Turkish, and Norwegian.

May 12, 2010


And apparently users in China have gone back to limbo given tor has been having trouble finding sources to connect even while using bridges.
Any light on that?


May 12, 2010


Not actually related to this entry, but I have to say...
Recently, Tor is becoming very unstable in China. The circuit seems to be established sometimes, but no data can be transfered over it. (i.e. HTTP GET request is very likely result a TIMEOUT)
Not sure what's happening there...Need you help.

I think the GFW might be traffic shaping the connections personally, though I can't be sure about that. The reason I say this is the bridges I run (that haven't been blocked) have been seeing very little throughput by the users which seems strange.


May 15, 2010


Looking at your metrics graphs, I'd say you need a new bridge distribution strategy for China. The number of users has fallen off a cliff and is now close to zero most of the time. The GFW is winning this contest.

We agree. We're trying a new one right now, it just has a slow ramp-up period by design. We're measuring the time duration from publishing bridges until they are blocked by the GFW.


May 16, 2010


just wondering if there are plans to include auto-update for Tor/Vidalia?
I have the combo running on an unattented machine to provide a relay but I worry that if it gets out-of-date it's not going to be as secure/useful.
Having a daily poll-update cycle that's seamless (though on Windows UC may be an issue) or at least downloads the update and flags in the UI that it's available would be very cool


May 25, 2010


Has the problem been resolved that was raised in Feb 2009 by a chinaman teacher/educator was it called something like "black hat" not sure